Miami outplayed Indianapolis in long stretches, picked off Daniel Jones twice, scored on defense — and lost by two. Because its kicker missed two field goals and an extra point. In a two-point loss. Do the math.
INDIANAPOLIS, Ind. — The Indianapolis Colts beat the Miami Dolphins 24–22 on Sunday at Lucas Oil Stadium, snapping a five-game losing streak and dropping Miami to 1–8. Rookie quarterback Kyle McCord made his first NFL start for Miami, in place of Malik Willis, and nearly stole a road win. Special teams gave it back.
Zane Gonzalez missed a 47-yard field goal in the first quarter, missed another field goal, and missed an extra point — seven points in total, in a game Miami lost by two. Head coach Jeff Hafley's postgame math was blunt: miss an extra point, you are forced to go for two late; miss two field goals, that's seven points. On Monday, Miami waived Gonzalez.
McCord's day was a real debut, flaws included. He finished 17-of-32 for 209 yards with three completions of 30-plus yards, ran for a late touchdown that pulled Miami within two, and also lost a fumble early in the third quarter that Indianapolis turned into a touchdown and a 21–7 lead. He was sacked three times. But from 21–7 down, he rallied and gave Miami a chance in the final two minutes before Indianapolis forced a turnover on downs in its own territory.
The defense deserved better. It held Daniel Jones to 108 passing yards, one touchdown and two interceptions, and Chris Johnson returned one of those picks 59 yards for a touchdown. Rookie Michael Taaffe added his third interception of the season. Where Miami cracked was on the ground: Jonathan Taylor and Seth McGowan led a 172-yard rushing day for Indianapolis, and linebacker Jordyn Brooks and the defense were the first to say afterward that giving up 17 offensive points still was not good enough.
That is why the kicking breakdown lands so hard — because so much else was good enough to win. A rookie quarterback making his first start on the road threw for 209 yards, hit three completions of 30-plus yards, and still had the composure to run in a late touchdown that pulled Miami within two. A defense that has taken its share of criticism held Jones to 108 passing yards, intercepted him twice, and scored itself when Johnson took a pick 59 yards the other way. Taaffe's third interception of the season was part of that same effort. Put those pieces together in most weeks and Miami walks out with a road win that changes the conversation around a 1–8 season, even if only for a few days.
Instead, the margin for error that Miami has lived with all season showed up again in the smallest plays. A missed 47-yarder in the first quarter does not feel decisive in the moment. A missed extra point does not always force a desperate two-point chase late. But add them together with another missed field goal, and seven points disappear in a game decided by two — and a fumble by McCord early in the third quarter, which Indianapolis turned into a touchdown and a 21–7 lead, becomes the other play Miami could not afford. Brooks and the defense saying 17 offensive points allowed still was not good enough tells you the standard inside that locker room, even if the record does not reflect it yet.
By the numbers: Final: Indianapolis 24, Miami 22 — quarters: Miami 0-7-9-6, Indianapolis 0-14-10-0. Kyle McCord (first NFL start): 17-of-32 for 209 yards, rushing TD, lost fumble. Zane Gonzalez: 2 missed field goals + 1 missed extra point = 7 points; waived Monday. Daniel Jones (IND): held to 108 yards, 1 TD, 2 INTs; Chris Johnson 59-yard INT return TD for Miami.
What's next: Miami travels to Buffalo to face the Bills (8–1) on Sunday, Nov. 22 at 1 p.m. McCord is expected to remain the starter for now — with a new kicker behind him.